Stutley, Margaret

   In her short volume on shamanism, Stutley states that shamanism is “one of the world’s most ancient, notorious and frequently misrepresented spiritual traditions,” but Shamanism: An Introduction (2003) is problematic in not offering convincing corrections to this imbalance. Instead, the book reifies the modernist principle of identifying similarities across space and time as an “urshamanism.” Claiming that “recent research indicates that shamanism represents the earliest religious experiences of mankind and therefore is important for the understanding of all human culture” (4), Stutley neglects the diversity of shamanisms, not to mention human cultures more generally, in favor of a metanarrative that locates “shamanism” as the single primordial, primitive religion and the origin of religion. In the vein of Mircea Eliade, this approach tells us very little about shamans in their specific community contexts or about the complexity of engagements between shamans and their communities. Furthermore, there is no discussion of postcolonial shamanism or the dynamic, if controversial, interface between indigenous shamans and neo-shamans. Rather than informing us about shamans past and present, this approach epitomizes the positioning of shamanism as “one of the phenomena against which modern western civilization has defined itself” (Hutton 2001, viii).

Historical dictionary of shamanism. . 2007.

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Bibliography —    As the scope of the dictionary entries and extent of this bibliography make clear, there is a huge range of literature on shamans, from introductory works, general discussions on such topics as definition, and culture specific ethnographic… …   Historical dictionary of shamanism

  • Shiva — For other uses, see Shiva (disambiguation). Shiva A statue de …   Wikipedia

  • Mantra — In Tibet, many Buddhists carve mantras into rocks as a form of meditation. A mantra (Tib.སྔགས་ ngak; Wyl. sngags) [1] is a sound, syllable, word, or group of words that is considered capable of creating transformation (cf. spiritual… …   Wikipedia

  • Mudra — This article is about the use of mudrā in Indic religion. For mudra as used in Indian classical music, see Mudra (music). Bharatnatyam dancer portraying Hindu goddess Lakshmi with her characteristic mudrās A mudrā (English: /muːˈdrɑː/ ( …   Wikipedia

  • Bibliography — Ali, Syed Mohammed. Hinduism: A Select Bibliography. Gurgaon: Indian Documentation Service, 1984. Ashby, Phillip H. Modern Trends in Hinduism. New York: Columbia University Press, 1974. Axel, Michaels, and Barbara Harshav. Hinduism: Past and… …   Encyclopedia of Hinduism

  • K'daai — Maqsin is a fire demon in Yakut mythology. He was the first blacksmith and the originator of ironworking. He lives in an iron house surrounded by flames. K daai is said to possess curative powers. In Yukut epics he heals the broken bones of… …   Wikipedia

  • Yekyua — is a class of Yakut spirits that remain hidden until the snow melts in the Spring. Each yekyua is associated with a particular animal, and they act as familiars for the Yakut shaman. The most powerful are attached to female shaman. The type of… …   Wikipedia

  • Imitation of sounds in shamanism — Shamanism in various cultures shows great diversity.[1] In some cultures, the music related to shamanistic beliefs or practice may intentionally mimic natural sounds, sometimes with onomatopoiea.[2] Of course, in several cultures, imitation of… …   Wikipedia

  • Deepavali — Divālī Les lampes dīp (ou diya), allumées en l honneur du retour de Rama à Ayodhya, et qui ont donné leur nom à Dīpāvalī …   Wikipédia en Français

  • Dipavali — Divālī Les lampes dīp (ou diya), allumées en l honneur du retour de Rama à Ayodhya, et qui ont donné leur nom à Dīpāvalī …   Wikipédia en Français

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”

We are using cookies for the best presentation of our site. Continuing to use this site, you agree with this.